 |  |  |  |
| Phillip Sheppard Winner Finalist | Rob Mariano Runner Up Finalist | David Murphy Runner Up #2 Finalist | Julie Wolfe 4th Place Jury |
| 7 votes | 1 vote | 1 vote | 2-2 vote 1-1 revote Tie Challenge |
 |  |  |  |  |
| Ralph Kiser 5th Place Jury | Matt Elrod 6th Place Jury Sent to RI: E9a | Mike Chiesl 7th Place Jury Sent to RI: E11a | Francesca Hogi 8th Place Jury Sent to RI: E13 | Steve Wright 9th Place Jury Sent to RI: E12 |
| 4-1 vote | 6-5 vote | 7-1 vote | 3-2 vote | 3-3 vote 2-2 revote Purple Rock |
 |  |  |  |  |
| Andrea Boehlke 10th Place Jury Sent to RI: E8 | Stephanie Valencia 11th Place Jury Sent to RI: E10 | Sarita White 12th Place Jury Sent to RI: E9b | Grant Mattos 13th Place Pre-Jury Sent to RI: E7 | Ashley Underwood 14th Place Pre-Jury Sent to RI: E6 |
| 7-5 vote | 7-2 vote | 9-1 vote | 3-3 vote 2-2 revote Purple Rock | 4-3 vote |
 |  |  |  |
| Kristina Kell 15th Place Pre-Jury Sent to RI: E4 | Natalie Tenerelli 16th Place Pre-Jury Sent to RI: E1 | Krista Klumpp 17th Place Pre-Jury Sent to RI: E3 | Russell Hantz 18th Place Pre-Jury Sent to RI: E2 |
| 5-3 vote | 5-4 vote | 5-3 vote | 4-4-1 vote 4-3 revote |
Proceed to the summary.