 |  |
| Sarita White | Stephanie Valencia |
| Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 |
Original Ometepe Tribe Alliance (4 strength)
 |  |
| Andrea Boehlke | Francesca Hogi |
| Loyalty: 4 | Loyalty: 4 |
Original Zapatera Tribe Alliance (3 strength)
 |  |  |
| David Murphy | Krista Klumpp | Mike Chiesl |
| Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 4 |
 |  | | |
| Ralph Kiser | Russell Hantz | Sarita White | Stephanie Valencia |
| Loyalty: 4 | Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 |
Proceed to redemption island.