 |  |  |  |
| Sherea Lloyd Winner Finalist | Dave Cruser Runner Up Finalist | Aaron Reisberger Runner Up #2 Finalist | Chicken Morris 4th Place Jury |
| 3 votes | 3 votes | 1 vote | 3-1 vote |
 |  |  |  |
| Jaime Dugan 5th Place Jury | Todd Herzog 6th Place Jury | Amanda Kimmel 7th Place Jury | Erik Huffman 8th Place Jury |
| 2-2-1 vote 2-1 revote | 3-2-1 vote | 3-2-2 vote | 4-2-2 vote |
 |  |  |  |
| James Clement 9th Place Jury | Denise Martin 10th Place Jury | Peih-Gee Law 11th Place Pre-Jury | Frosti Zernow 12th Place Pre-Jury |
| 5-4 vote | 5-2 vote | 3-2 vote |
 |  |  |  |
| Jean-Robert Bellande 13th Place Pre-Jury | Courtney Yates 14th Place Pre-Jury | Ashley Massaro 15th Place Pre-Jury | Leslie Nease 16th Place Pre-Jury |
3-1 revote | 5-2 vote | 5-3 vote | 4-2-2 vote |