 |  |
| Jerri Manthey | Sandra Diaz-Twine |
| Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 |
Original Heroes Tribe Alliance (4 strength)
 |  |  |
| Amanda Kimmel | Candice Woodcock | Colby Donaldson |
| Loyalty: 5 | Loyalty: 4 | Loyalty: 4 |
 |  |  |  |
| James Thomas | Stephenie LaGrossa | Jessica Kiper | Tom Westman |
| Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 4 | Loyalty: 5 |
Original Villains Tribe Alliance (4 strength)
 | | |
| Rob Mariano | Jerri Manthey | Sandra Diaz-Twine |
| Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 3 | Loyalty: 5 |
Proceed to the immunity challenge.